Capt. married Anne Maria Dyer Phelps. Anne (daughter of Henry Ernest Dyer and Mary Rice Dyer) was born 3 September 1696, Hebron, Tolland, Connecticut, Colonies of America; died 4 May 1764, Kent, Litchfield County, Connecticut. [Group Sheet]

1. Margaret Rose Withers was born 5 Nov 1927, Pennsylvania; died 26 Feb 1996, Shippensburg, Cumberland, Pennsylvania, USA.
2. Capt. Noah Amherst Phelps, Jr was born 21 Nov 1720, Hebron, Hartford County, Connecticut, USA; died 10 Jan 1795, Austerlitz, Columbia County, New York, USA.
3. Barrett Phelps was born 20 Sep 1722, Hebron, Tolland, Connecticut; died August 1789, Cambridge, Washington, New York, USA.
4. ELIJAH PHELPS was born 31 Jul 1724, Hebron, Tolland, Connecticut; died Abt. 1783, Amenia, Dutchless, New York, USA.
5. Mary Phelps was born 1 May 1726, Hebron, Tolland, Connecticut; died 31 Dec 1771, Hebron, Connecticut.
6. Hannah Hulda Phelps was born 28 Feb 1727, Hebron, Tolland, Connecticut, USA; died 1803, Bainbridge, Chenango, New York, USA.
7. Anne Phelps was born 1 Feb 1730, Hebron; died 25 Nov 1799, Westfield, Hampden, Massachusetts, United States.
8. Sarah A Phelps was born 22 Jan 1731, Middletown, Middlesex, Connecticut, USA; died 1741, Y, Somme, Picardie, France.
9. Capt. James Phelps, Sr. was born 27 May 1732, Hebron, Tolland, Connecticut, USA; died 10 March 1831, Southwick, Hampden, MA, Massachusetts, USA.
10. Martha Phelps was born 12 Mar 1733, Middletown, Middlesex, Connecticut; died 1743.
11. Abijah James Phelps was born 8 Mar 1734, Hebron, Connecticut; died 10 Apr 1837, Hillsdale, Columbia, New York.
12. Asa C Phelps, Sr was born 15 Jan 1736, Middletown, Middlesex, Connecticut; died 3 April 1813, Rensslaerville, Albany Co., New York, USA.
13. Lazarus Phelps was born 1738, Hebron, Tolland, Connecticut, United States; died 1739.
14. Jonah Phelps was born 11 Oct 1744, Hebron, Tolland, Connecticut, British North America; died 26 Mar 1826, Green River, Columbia, New York, USA.